Ch 4

Reporting Attitude and Nuance

She claimed that… · She made a suggestion · She asked whether to wait · no backshift

Building on B2

Reporting what people meant, not just what they said

At B2 you used reporting verbs like offer to, deny -ing, advise someone to. C1 adds verbs that show the speaker's attitude, reporting with nouns, and choices about tense.

Verbs that show attitude

How sure or how willing the speaker was

claim / allege
He claimed that he had been at home. (maybe not true)
maintain / insist
She maintained that the decision was fair. (kept saying it)
concede / admit
The coach conceded that the team had played badly. (reluctantly)
point out / stress
She pointed out that the shop was closed.

Reporting with nouns

Summarise the speech act — formal and concise

"Why don't we leave early?" → She made a suggestion: to leave early.
"Don't go near the edge!" → The guide issued a warning about the cliffs.
"It wasn't me." → He made a denial / denied any involvement.
suggest / insist / recommend that + (should) + base: see the Subjunctive chapter.

To backshift or not?

The speaker's point of view decides

"The Earth goes round the Sun." → She explained that the Earth goes round the Sun.
Still true → no backshift needed.
"I'm moving to Rome." → He told me he is moving to Rome next month.
Still in the future → present is fine.
"You must come." → She said I had to come / must come.
would, could, might, should stay the same.

Reporting questions: whether + to

Asking what to do

"Should I wait?" → She asked whether to wait.
"Where should we park?" → They wondered where to park.
He couldn't decide whether or not to accept.

Common mistakes

Where learners go wrong most often

She did a suggestion.
→
She made a suggestion.
make a suggestion / a complaint / a promise
He gave an apology for us.
→
He apologised to us / offered an apology.
noun + verb collocation
She asked if to wait.
→
She asked whether to wait.
whether + to (not if + to)
He claimed to be at home at the time.
→
He claimed to have been at home at the time.
earlier time → to have + PP

Your turn

Answer out loud — full sentences

Report with attitude.

1
Report something a politician claimed recently.
2
Report a time someone insisted that you do something.
3
Summarise a conversation using nouns: made a suggestion, gave a warning, offered an apology.
4
Report a question someone asked you about what to do.

Recap

doubtful report
claim / allege that
He claimed that …
kept saying
maintain / insist that
She maintained that …
reluctant
concede / admit that
He conceded that …
summary noun
make a suggestion · issue a warning
She made a complaint.
still true
no backshift
She said the Earth goes round the Sun.
what to do
whether / where + to
She asked whether to wait.